top of page

Registered, Yet Infringing: How Article 155 Treats Later Trademarks in Turkey

6 days ago
8 min read
KEY TAKEAWAY: In Turkey, a trademark registration gives the right to stop others, not a right of use against earlier right holders. Under Article 155 of Code 6769, a later registration cannot be relied on as a defence in an infringement action brought by the owner of an earlier-filed right. Under the former Decree-Law No. 556, by contrast, use in the registered form was lawful until invalidation, save in bad faith. The applicable regime generally depends on the date of the action. Evidence of use filed in oppositions or invalidation actions may later be turned against the party that filed it.

A company registers its mark with the Turkish Patent and Trademark Office ("TPTO") and trades under it for years. Then a competitor with an earlier application for a similar mark sends a cease-and-desist letter. The usual reaction is: "We have a registration too." Under the Industrial Property Code No. 6769 ("Code 6769"), that answer does not work against an earlier right holder.


This article covers Article 155, the former regime, transitional issues, a common procedural mistake and a comparison with EU law, based on recent decisions of the Turkish Court of Cassation (Yargıtay). Decisions are cited by chamber, file number – decision number and date; "11th CC" refers to the Court's 11th Civil Chamber.


Ivan Konstantinovich Aivazovsky (1817-1900), Moonlight in Crimea
Ivan Konstantinovich Aivazovsky (1817-1900), “Moonlight in Crimea”

What Does Article 155 Provide?

Article 155 of Code 6769 reads: "The owner of a trademark, patent or design right may not invoke its industrial property right as a defence in an infringement action brought by right holders with an earlier priority or filing date." The provision applies to trademarks, patents and designs alike; this article focuses on trademarks.


The relevant comparison is between filing (or priority) dates, not registration dates. A later-filed mark that happens to have been registered first is therefore in no better position. The rule is consistent with the nature of trademark rights: Article 7(2) of Code 6769 gives the owner the right to prevent certain uses by others, not a freedom to use the mark against earlier right holders.


The Court of Cassation applies the rule consistently. In a case where the defendant held both a registered trademark and a registered trade name, the Court held that the defendant could not invoke rights deriving from its later registration in the infringement action and reversed the dismissal of the claim (11th CC, 2024/2460 – 2025/1301, 26.02.2025; majority decision). First-instance and regional court judgments to the same effect are regularly upheld (11th CC, 2025/1852 – 2025/6693; 11th CC, 2025/5436 – 2026/2486).


The Former Regime: The "Registration Shield" under Decree-Law No. 556

Before Code 6769 entered into force on 10 January 2017, the position was different. Decree-Law No. 556 contained no equivalent of Article 155, and the Court of Cassation treated the use of a registered mark, until its removal from the register, as the lawful exercise of a right.


The Grand Civil Chamber summarised this approach as follows: until an invalidation action is concluded, use of the later mark cannot be prevented even if the registration was wrongly granted; use of a registered mark in accordance with its registration does not constitute infringement or unfair competition until the mark is removed from the register (Grand Civil Chamber, 2023/83 – 2023/7, 01.02.2023). In the same dispute, the 11th Civil Chamber had held that the defendant was legally entitled to use its registered mark until the invalidity judgment became final (11th CC, 2012/11560 – 2013/10907). Earlier Chamber decisions are to the same effect (11th CC, 2008/14118 – 2010/10148; 11th CC, 2014/12345 – 2014/14249).


This "registration shield" had two important exceptions:


  • Bad-faith registration: In the same judgment, the Grand Civil Chamber held that a registration obtained in bad faith cannot serve as a justification and that even use in the registered form constitutes infringement and unfair competition (Grand Civil Chamber, 2023/83 – 2023/7, 01.02.2023).

  • Use not in the registered form: Where the defendant used a registered mark not as registered but by emphasising the dominant element of the plaintiff's mark, the Grand Civil Chamber found infringement (Grand Civil Chamber, 2017/100 – 2018/228, 14.02.2018). Infringement was likewise found where the defendant used its registered mark in a form approximating the plaintiff's mark (11th CC, 2021/5331 – 2022/7666).


Outside these exceptions, the earlier right holder first had to obtain an invalidity judgment, and infringement claims were often stayed pending the outcome of the invalidation action.


The Rule under Code 6769

The Court of Cassation has expressly stated that the principle that a later industrial property right cannot be invoked as a defence in infringement proceedings was introduced for trademarks for the first time by Article 155 of Code 6769 (11th CC, 2025/2571 – 2025/7814, 25.12.2025). The earlier right holder may therefore seek an injunction without first invalidating the later mark; in practice, invalidation and infringement claims are typically combined.


The Court reversed a regional court judgment that had dismissed an infringement claim against a defendant with a later registered mark, holding that "the fact that the defendant's mark was registered after the plaintiff's mark does not mean that it cannot infringe the plaintiff's mark" (11th CC, 2025/3792 – 2026/504, 27.01.2026; majority decision). In short, a registration does not make use of the mark lawful as against owners of earlier rights.


Transitional Issues: Which Law Applies?

Often the defendant's mark predates Code 6769 while the action does not. According to the Court of Cassation, applications are examined under the law in force on their filing date (Provisional Article 1(1)), but invalidation and infringement actions filed after 10 January 2017 are governed by Code 6769 (11th CC, 2020/1412 – 2021/2516, 17.03.2021). The decisive date is, as a rule, the date of the action:


  • 11th CC, 2025/2571 – 2025/7814 (defendant's mark from the Decree-Law era; action filed on 30.06.2016): Decree-Law No. 556 applies; the registered mark does not infringe until invalidated, and the outcome of the invalidation action must be awaited.

  • 11th CC, 2025/3792 – 2026/504 (defendant's mark filed on 28.12.2016, before Code 6769; action filed under Code 6769): Code 6769 applies; the later registration does not exclude infringement.

  • 11th CC, 2023/5412 – 2024/7070 (defendant's mark filed in 2016; action filed on 21.12.2018): Article 155 applies; both invalidation and infringement were upheld.


A Common Mistake: "Acquired Rights" and Evidence of Use Can Backfire

Claims of Acquired Rights in Oppositions

Applicants facing an opposition often claim an "acquired right" (müktesep hak) and file evidence of many years of use. Under Turkish case law, however, an acquired right can only derive from an earlier registered mark of the applicant, not from unregistered use. In a judgment upheld by the Court of Cassation, the cumulative conditions were: the essential element of the earlier registered mark must be preserved in the new mark, the earlier mark must have been used without challenge for at least as long as an invalidation action could have been brought, there must be no intention to approach the opponent's mark, and the list of goods and services must not be extended (11th CC, 2024/6268 – 2025/4829). Claims based on unregistered use cannot be assessed in registration proceedings and may only be raised in infringement actions (11th CC, 2020/1330 – 2021/662).


Relying on an Earlier Registration Is Not Enough Either

Applicants often also rely on an earlier registration in their own name. If that registration is itself later than the opponent's mark, it does not help, for two reasons. First, it is itself exposed to invalidation. In an action against an ex officio refusal, the first-instance court held that a mark registered less than five years earlier, and thus still exposed to invalidation, could not ground an acquired right; the Court of Cassation rejected the appeal on that point, while reversing on another ground (11th CC, 2025/4625 – 2026/1705, 25.03.2026).


Second, and more importantly, the acquired-rights debate only concerns whether the new application can be registered; it does not legitimise use of the earlier registration. Being later than the opponent's mark, that registration cannot be invoked as a defence in infringement proceedings either (Article 155). The "earlier registration plus evidence of use" package may thus show that use under the earlier registration also infringes the opponent's mark, and since when; for the opponent, it is a valuable starting point for invalidation and infringement proceedings. Whether the opponent knowingly tolerated that use for five consecutive years (Article 25(6)) must be assessed separately.


Evidence of Use in Invalidation Actions

Defendants in invalidation actions also file extensive evidence of use to support acquiescence, coexistence or acquired distinctiveness. Under the former regime this was usually harmless. Under Code 6769, if the defence fails, the same evidence may prove the existence, duration and scope of infringement, and sales invoices may feed into damages under Article 151, notably the infringer's-profit method.


In a recent case, the defendant stated in its answer that it had used the sign for over thirty years but had "never formalised" this. Applying Article 155, and noting that the actual use also differed from the registered form, the court found infringement and awarded TRY 165,759.41 in material damages calculated on the defendant's net profit and TRY 20,000 in moral damages; the judgment was upheld (11th CC, 2025/4689 – 2026/2403, 28.04.2026).


Every piece of evidence and every statement filed in oppositions, responses and invalidation actions should therefore be assessed with a possible infringement action in mind, and only what is necessary for the legal argument at hand should be filed.


Damages: Fault Still Matters

Article 155 removes the later registration as a defence to infringement, but not the fault requirement for damages. In a design case, the Court of Cassation held that before awarding damages the court must examine whether the defendant knew or should have known of the earlier right, relying on Article 45 of TRIPS and on the wording of Article 155, which refers only to the "infringement action" (11th CC, 2020/1455 – 2022/4194, 30.05.2022).


Comparison with EU Law

For EU practitioners, the Turkish rule will look familiar. In Fédération Cynologique Internationale (C-561/11, 21 February 2013), the Court of Justice of the European Union held that the exclusive right of the proprietor of a Community trade mark extends to a third party that owns a later registered Community trade mark, without the need for that later mark to have been declared invalid beforehand. Article 155 of Code 6769 reflects the same priority principle.


The EU framework, however, adds a counterweight. Under Article 18 of Directive (EU) 2015/2436, the earlier proprietor cannot prohibit use of a later registered mark that could not be declared invalid, for instance because of acquiescence or non-use of the earlier mark; the later proprietor then cannot prohibit use of the earlier mark either. Code 6769 has no express equivalent of this "intervening right". Similar results are reached through separate defences: non-use (Article 29(2), referring to Article 19(2)), acquiescence in invalidation actions (Article 25(6)) and the general good-faith rule of the Civil Code.


The Court of Cassation has, for instance, noted that Code 6769 contains no specific rule on acquiescence in infringement actions, and held that although the defendant could not rely on its later registration under Article 155, the lower court should have examined its separate argument, based on the good-faith rule, that the plaintiff had tolerated its use for many years (11th CC, 2024/3651 – 2025/2081, 24.03.2025).


Conclusion

Under Code 6769, a trademark registration in Turkey is not a shield against owners of earlier rights. In practice:


  1. Clearance searches should be carried out before use begins, not after registration is granted.

  2. Registered marks should be used as registered and not approximated to third-party marks.

  3. Acquired-rights arguments and evidence of use should be framed with a possible infringement action in mind.

  4. The applicable regime should be identified at the outset by reference to the date of the action.


Legislation and case law

Industrial Property Code No. 6769, Arts. 7, 19, 25, 27, 29, 151, 155, Provisional Art. 1 · Former Decree-Law No. 556 · TRIPS Art. 45 · Directive (EU) 2015/2436, Art. 18 · CJEU, C-561/11, Fédération Cynologique Internationale, 21.02.2013


Court of Cassation, Grand Civil Chamber: 01.02.2023, 2023/83 – 2023/7 · 14.02.2018, 2017/100 – 2018/228


Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber: 2012/11560 – 2013/10907 · 2008/14118 – 2010/10148 · 2014/12345 – 2014/14249 · 2021/5331 – 2022/7666 · 17.03.2021, 2020/1412 – 2021/2516 · 30.05.2022, 2020/1455 – 2022/4194 · 2023/5412 – 2024/7070 · 26.02.2025, 2024/2460 – 2025/1301 · 24.03.2025, 2024/3651 – 2025/2081 · 2024/6268 – 2025/4829 · 2025/1852 – 2025/6693 · 25.12.2025, 2025/2571 – 2025/7814 · 27.01.2026, 2025/3792 – 2026/504 · 25.03.2026, 2025/4625 – 2026/1705 · 28.04.2026, 2025/4689 – 2026/2403 · 2025/5436 – 2026/2486 · 2020/1330 – 2021/662


This article is intended for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.


For trademark infringement and invalidation actions, oppositions and responses before the TPTO, and pre-launch clearance in Turkey, please contact us at info@goklulaw.com.


Key Contact:

Evren Fırat Göklü

Founding Partner | Attorney at Law | Trademark & Patent Attorney

 
 
bottom of page