Design License Agreements in Turkey: Exclusive Licenses, Multiple Designs, Royalties and the Overlap with Copyright
KEY TAKEAWAY: Inserting into a design license agreed as exclusive a clause allowing the licensor to license others does not turn the license into a non-exclusive one. The Court of Cassation held that, in an agreement which by its title, recitals and other provisions granted an exclusive license, a clause authorising the licensor to grant licenses to third parties was void as contrary to the mandatory rule on exclusive licenses, and that this invalidity did not affect the agreement as a whole. Since nothing to the contrary had been agreed, the exclusive licensee could sue an infringing third party in its own name; the Court reversed the regional court of appeal, which had treated the license as a simple license (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, 30.06.2020, File No. 2019/5415, Decision No. 2020/3339). The same rules are now found in Arts. 75/2 and 158/1 of Code 6769. Design license agreements should therefore regulate the type of license, the licensor's own right to use and the power to sue consistently with one another.
In sectors such as fashion and textiles, furniture, home textiles, carpets, packaging and accessories, designs are often exploited through licensing rather than by the design owner's own production. Designers and design studios licensing their designs to manufacturers, brands licensing product designs to contract manufacturers, and collection-based collaborations all derive their legal basis from design license agreements.
This article examines the types of design licenses under Turkish law, the mandatory rules on exclusive licenses, the scope of licenses over multiple designs, formal requirements and recordal, the licensee's right to sue, the effect of invalidity on royalties, the license fee method in infringement damages, unregistered designs and the relationship with copyright, in light of recent decisions of the Turkish Court of Cassation.

Legal Framework
Design licensing is governed by Art. 75 of the Industrial Property Code No. 6769 ("Code 6769"). The licensor's liability is set out in Art. 76 and the effect of invalidity in Art. 79. The rules on written form and recordal applicable to all industrial property rights are in Art. 148, and the licensee's right to sue is in Art. 158. The documents required for recordal of a license are listed in Art. 69 of the Regulation on the Implementation of the Industrial Property Code ("Regulation"). The Turkish Patent and Trademark Office ("TPTO") keeps the register in which licenses are recorded.
A license agreement is not a contract type regulated in the Turkish Code of Obligations. The Court of Cassation treats license agreements as atypical contracts and applies, as far as possible, the rules of the contract type they most closely resemble. The parties' rights and obligations should therefore be expressly regulated in the agreement.
Types of License and the Mandatory Rule on Exclusive Licenses
Under Art. 75/2 of Code 6769, a license may be exclusive or non-exclusive, and unless otherwise agreed, it is non-exclusive. Under a non-exclusive license, the licensor may use the design itself and grant further licenses to third parties. Under an exclusive license, the licensor may not grant licenses to others and, unless it has expressly reserved the right, may not use the design itself.
The practical significance of this rule is clearly illustrated by a case before the Court of Cassation. A textile company had signed an agreement titled "exclusive license agreement" with the owner of a multiple design registration. However, one clause of the agreement provided that the licensor could license the same design to one or more companies and could use the design itself. The licensee sued a manufacturer copying the design for infringement, and the first instance court upheld the action.
The regional court of appeal, relying on that clause, held that the agreement was in fact a non-exclusive license, that the word "exclusive" in the title did not change its nature, and that the licensee as a rule had no right to sue; it dismissed the action. The Court of Cassation reversed. In its view, the parties had agreed on an exclusive license; the clause authorising the licensor to license third parties was void as contrary to the mandatory rule on exclusive licenses. That invalidity did not render the agreement as a whole invalid, and the parties' intention could not be interpreted by relying on a void clause taken out of context. Since nothing to the contrary had been agreed, the exclusive licensee could bring in its own name the actions available to the design owner in the event of infringement (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, 30.06.2020, File No. 2019/5415, Decision No. 2020/3339). Although the decision was based on Art. 41 of the former Decree-Law No. 554, the same rules are now found in Arts. 75/2 and 158/1 of Code 6769.
Another notable aspect of the decision is that the exclusive licensee's right to sue the infringer was accepted even though the license had not been recorded. Nevertheless, given that an unrecorded license cannot be asserted against third parties acting in good faith (Art. 148/5), recordal of the license should not be neglected.
A structure frequently sought in practice is a sole license, under which the licensor continues its own production. This can be achieved, as permitted by Art. 75/2, by the licensor expressly reserving its own right to use. The licensor's ability to license third parties, however, is incompatible with an exclusive license; in that case, the agreement should be split, for example as exclusive for a particular territory or sales channel and non-exclusive for others.
Scope of the License: Multiple Designs, Territory and Products
Under Art. 69/1 of the Regulation, the right to use a design may be licensed for the whole or part of the national territory. This allows, for example, a design to be licensed to one manufacturer for the Marmara region and to another for the Aegean region. For territorial licenses, the treatment of sales outside the territory, particularly through e-commerce and online marketplaces, should be addressed separately.
For multiple design registrations, the agreement should clearly state which designs the license covers. Under Art. 69/2-b of the Regulation, the license agreement submitted for recordal must show the sequence numbers of the licensed designs for multiple applications. Annexing the design images in addition to the sequence numbers significantly reduces disputes over the scope of the license.
The design right covers products identical to the design, or not distinguishable from it in terms of overall impression (Art. 81/1-a). Whether modifications made by the licensee remain within the scope of the license should therefore be addressed separately in the agreement. Who will own new designs derived by the licensee from the licensed design, and in whose name they will be registered, should also be clearly determined.
Sublicensing, Transfer and Exceeding the Scope of the License
Unless otherwise agreed, licensees may not transfer their rights under the license to third parties or grant sublicenses (Art. 75/3). Given how common contract manufacturing is in design licensing, it may become disputed whether having products made by a third-party manufacturer amounts to a sublicense. Permission to use contract manufacturers should therefore be expressly addressed.
Under Art. 75/4, unless otherwise agreed, the licensee may carry out all acts relating to the use of the design during the term of the license; however, it must comply with the terms of the agreement, failing which the design owner may assert its design rights against the licensee. Art. 81/1-b treats the unauthorised extension of rights granted by license, or their transfer to third parties, as design infringement. Continuing production after the license expires, or using the design on products outside the scope of the license, may therefore constitute design infringement in addition to breach of contract.
Co-Ownership
Where a design is co-owned, licensing to third parties requires the unanimous consent of the co-owners; if unanimity cannot be reached, the court may, on equitable grounds, confer the power to license on one or more of them (Art. 70/3). Where a designer and a manufacturer, or two design studios, are co-owners, it is recommended that the power to license be regulated from the outset in a co-ownership agreement.
Formal Requirements, Recordal and the Right to Sue
A design license agreement must be in writing (Art. 148/4). Unlike assignments, notarization is not required for licenses. However, rights arising from unrecorded licenses cannot be asserted against third parties acting in good faith (Art. 148/5). Under Art. 69/2 of the Regulation, the license agreement submitted for recordal must contain the signatures and declarations of the parties, the name and registration number of the design, the sequence numbers for multiple applications, and the license fee and term if any. Where the commercial terms are to remain confidential, a short license summary containing only these elements may be prepared and used for recordal.
An important rule protecting licensees concerns surrender. The design owner cannot surrender the design right without the consent of recorded right holders and licensees (Art. 80/4). This protection applies only to recorded licenses and is on its own a sufficient reason to record the license.
The licensee's right to sue is governed by Art. 158. Unless otherwise agreed, an exclusive licensee may bring in its own name the actions available to the design owner. A non-exclusive licensee, unless its right to sue is expressly restricted in the agreement, must first request by notice that the design owner bring the action; if the owner refuses or does not bring the action within three months of the notice, the licensee may sue in its own name, to the extent of its own interest, attaching the notice. Where there is a risk of serious harm, the licensee may request a preliminary injunction before the three-month period expires (Art. 158/3). In sectors selling seasonal products, such as fashion and textiles, it is recommended that these powers be expressly regulated so that infringements can be addressed quickly.
Licensor's Liability and Invalidity of the Design
If it subsequently emerges that the licensor was not entitled to grant the license, the licensor is liable to the persons concerned (Art. 76/1). Where the design application is withdrawn or refused, or the registration is revoked or invalidated, Art. 79 applies unless the parties have provided for broader liability (Art. 76/2).
Under Art. 79, an invalidity decision has retroactive effect and the protection is deemed never to have arisen. However, the retroactive effect does not affect contracts concluded and performed before the invalidity decision, and a full or partial refund of amounts paid under such contracts may be claimed on equitable grounds (Arts. 79/2-b and 79/3). In a dispute concerning patent licenses, to which the same rule applies, the Court of Cassation interpreted the equitable reduction narrowly where the licensee had manufactured products under the license (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, 25.09.2023, File No. 2022/476, Decision No. 2023/5316).
This risk is particularly significant for designs. Design registrations are frequently challenged in invalidity actions on the ground that they lack novelty and individual character in view of identical or similar designs made available to the public anywhere in the world before the filing date. Unlike patents, Art. 76 does not link the licensor's failure to disclose information on registrability to a presumption of bad faith. The licensee's protection is therefore left largely to the agreement, which should regulate:
The licensor's representations and warranties that the design was not made available to the public before the filing date, and as to prior designs known to it,
What happens to royalties if the design is invalidated, and partial refund of any upfront fee,
Who will conduct the defence, and at whose cost, if an invalidity action is brought.
No Use Requirement, but Contractual Targets
Code 6769 does not impose a use requirement on designs as it does for trademarks and patents. A registered design remains valid throughout its term even if not used. This is an advantage for the licensor; however, if the licensee never uses a design licensed to it exclusively, the licensor may in practice lose the ability to generate income from the design.
Particularly in exclusive design licenses, it is therefore recommended to include minimum production or sales targets, a minimum royalty, and provisions such as conversion of the license into a non-exclusive one, or termination, if the targets are not met.
Term and Renewal
Registered designs are protected for five years from the filing date, renewable for successive five-year periods up to a total of twenty-five years; the right in a design that is not renewed ends on the expiry date (Art. 69). Where the license term spans one or more renewal periods, the agreement should regulate the design owner's obligation to renew and to notify the licensee reasonably in advance if it will not renew. The situation discussed in our article on trademark licenses, where a non-renewed trademark leaves the licensee unprotected, applies equally to designs.
The License Fee Method in Infringement Damages
License agreements are also important for calculating damages in infringement actions. Under Art. 151/2-c of Code 6769, lost profits may, at the right holder's option, be calculated on the basis of the license fee the infringer would have paid had it used the design lawfully under a license agreement.
In a design infringement case, the Court of Cassation, referring to its earlier reversal decision, stated that the license fee cannot be calculated solely on the basis of the claimant's turnover, and that factors such as comparable license fees, the reputation of the design, whether other licenses exist and the term of protection of the design must be taken into account. The first instance court, having complied with the earlier reversal but without conducting such an enquiry, relied this time on a calculation based on the infringer's revenues, which was again held to be a ground for reversal (Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber, 23.10.2017, File No. 2016/3765, Decision No. 2017/5579). The Court emphasised that where no comparable license fee is submitted, an expert report should be obtained from a panel that includes a design expert.
This decision shows how valuable it is for design owners to document existing license agreements and royalty rates regularly, as evidence of damages in any future infringement action.
Unregistered Designs and the Overlap with Copyright
Designs first made available to the public in Turkey are protected as unregistered designs for three years from that date (Arts. 55/4 and 69/2). Since unregistered designs are not entered in the register, licenses over them cannot be recorded either, and their enforceability against third parties rests entirely on the agreement. Licenses of unregistered designs should annex the date on which the design was first made available to the public, the documents evidencing it and the design images. The fact that an unregistered design is protected only against copying (Art. 59/2) should also be taken into account in setting the royalty.
An original piece of furniture, pattern or accessory may be protected not only by design rights but also as a work under the Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846 ("Copyright Law"). Under Art. 58/3 of Code 6769, design protection is without prejudice to the protection provided by the Copyright Law where its requirements are met. However, the conditions under which a design is also protected as a work, i.e. the scope of cumulative protection, is a contested issue and will be addressed in a separate article. What matters for licensing is that, where the design may qualify as a work, the licensee may also need permission to use the economic rights in the work. Under Art. 52 of the Copyright Law, contracts and dispositions relating to economic rights must be in writing and the rights concerned must be specified individually. For designs that may qualify as works, it is therefore a prudent approach for the license agreement to also grant permission to use economic rights such as adaptation, reproduction and distribution, listing them individually.
Competition Law Dimension
Design license agreements should be assessed under Art. 4 of the Law on the Protection of Competition No. 4054 where they contain, in particular, exclusivity, territorial and customer restrictions, resale price restrictions or non-compete obligations. The Competition Board's Block Exemption Communiqué on Technology Transfer Agreements (Communiqué No. 2008/2) includes industrial designs in its definition of intellectual property rights. Licenses below certain market share thresholds and not containing the hardcore restrictions listed in the communiqué may benefit from the block exemption. Provisions such as fixing the resale price are particularly risky in this respect.
Conclusion
Although a design license agreement can be concluded in writing without notarization, it requires careful preparation because of the mandatory rules on license types, scope issues with multiple designs and the possible overlap with copyright. An internally inconsistent exclusivity provision may call into question the licensee's right to sue for infringement. A license that does not specify sequence numbers may lead to disputes over scope. An unrecorded license may leave the licensee unprotected against the design owner unilaterally surrendering the design. Design licenses should therefore be prepared with an approach that takes into account both the specific rules of design law and its possible overlap with copyright.
Legislation and Case Law Referred To
Industrial Property Code No. 6769, Arts. 55, 58, 59, 69, 70, 75, 76, 79, 80, 81, 148, 151, 158 · Regulation on the Implementation of the Industrial Property Code, Art. 69 · Law on Intellectual and Artistic Works No. 5846, Art. 52 · Law on the Protection of Competition No. 4054, Art. 4 · Block Exemption Communiqué on Technology Transfer Agreements (No. 2008/2)
Court of Cassation, 11th Civil Chamber: 30.06.2020, 2019/5415 – 2020/3339 · 23.10.2017, 2016/3765 – 2017/5579 · 25.09.2023, 2022/476 – 2023/5316
This article is intended for general information purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.
To prepare and negotiate design license agreements in Turkey, structure collection- and product-based licensing arrangements, and record licenses with the TPTO, please contact us at info@goklulaw.com.
Key Contact:
Evren Fırat Göklü
Founding Partner | Attorney at Law | Trademark & Patent Attorney



